The biggest problem has been the efforts of preening BBC directors to put their own ' interpretation' on James' stories instead of just putting the story on the screen, Ghost Stories for Christmas adaptations being the usual offenders. After placing his ailing wife Alice (Gemma Jones) in a care home, retired academic James Parkin (John Hurt) goes to stay at a wintry out-of-season hotel which they used to visit together. Maybe they should have changed the title, as well, to something like "Ring for me and I'll come?" James's original tale are nowhere to be found, and the haunted whistle has been replaced with a ring. Jack Heller With a plot revolving around several apparent strangers stranded at an isolated cabin in the creepy backwoods of beyond, audiences could be forgiven for assuming The Haunting of Black Wood is a tired retread of the likes of The Evil Dead and The Cabin in the Woods . Whistle and I'll come to you (2010) - spoilers. Prime members enjoy FREE Delivery and exclusive access to music, movies, TV shows, original audio series, and Kindle books. But it's still utterly terrifying, John Hurt . Pain, sorrow, loneliness, horror, and an abomination from beyond combine to make this story truly frightening. This is a must see for drama students and theatre goers alike. James Parkin (John Hurt) encounters an apparition on a desolate British beach - … Can't understand the negative reviews of this decent,imaginative ghost story.For me the presence of John Hurt as the main character,Parkins makes this made for tv effort a very enjoyable ride. Sign in to see videos available to you. I recently saw both versions of "Whistle and I'll come to you" for the first time and thoroughly enjoyed both but was somewhat surprised to come on here and see all the negative reviews for the remake. While cataloging the library of Barchester Cathedral, a scholar finds a diary detailing the events surrounding the mysterious death of an Archdeacon some 50 years earlier. Whistle & I'll come to you (2010) Can't understand the negative reviews of this decent,imaginative ghost story.For me the presence of John Hurt as the main character,Parkins makes this made for tv effort a very enjoyable ride. He plays the Scrooge figure in Steven Moffat's clever remix of A Christmas Carol. Abby Howard adapted the story as a web comic. It was a waste of his talent, and proves to be a waste of your time. So this may help to redress the balance a little. A young orphan, Stephen, is sent to go and live with his strange, much older cousin at his remote country house. After discovering a mysterious ring on the beach, a university professor (John Hurt) finds his rational beliefs challenged by a series of supernatural occurrences during a vacation to the coast. It isn't, however, being instead an unwarranted 'Disneyfication' of a far darker psychological piece that a new audience will mistakenly equate with Britain's greatest master of the macabre. It's many years since I read the M.R. This is a modern version of the classic MR James ghost story 'Whistle and I'll Come To You'. Abby Howard adapted the story as a web comic. On his return to England he ... See full summary ». Whistle and I'll Come to You: Preview clip Watch an exclusive clip from Whistle and I'll come to you. To his credit Neil Cross has tried to find a modern way into the story and has turned it into a tale about a man whose wife is lost to Alzheimer's. A haunting and bittersweet adaptation of M.R. Ah yes, the ending. No, I never read the original novel or saw the 1968 movie. But unfortunately, this "horror" story plods along so slowly that at times you almost wish that you could trade places with his dementia-filled wife who just sits there staring blankly, something that you'll soon find yourself doing after about 30 minutes. The story tells the tale of an introverted academic who happens upon a strange whistle while exploring a Knights Templar cemetery on the East Anglian coast. It's polished like the silver and looks lovely; the class divide and its interdependency is endlessly fascinating. Starring: John Hurt, Gemma Jones, Lesley Sharp. The original story describes the horror when the supernatural breaks out of the confines of abstract theory and scornful dismissal into a very real manifestation. ... See full summary ». Producing a piece about the grief of aging and dementia is surely a worthy cause in itself, but who on earth had the idea of hitching this topic to a classic ghost story that, in its original form, does not offer the slightest connection to such themes? Written by Neil Cross of Luther fame, this 2010 retelling of M.R. He bounds about enthusiastically in space and time, fixing things, making it better. This is somewhat true on the face of it, but also beside the point. Photograph: Laurie Spaham/BBC, t was a Christmas of ghosts and of the past. What survives though is the spirit of the story – a man, alone by the sea, haunted, pursued by something. A lonely Signalman is visited by a stranger. Looking for some great streaming picks? As an archaeologist, he has been engaged by the squire to catalogue a private collection of local artefacts. A splendid performance from Michael Hordern. If you've never even heard of the titular story, you may actually appreciate this film—in fact, I'll up my rating by one star for John Hurt's performance alone. It's MR James, the great ghost story writer, turning in his grave at Whistle and I'll Come to You (BBC2, Christmas Eve). Shhh, what's that noise? James's overconfident scholar and protagonist is the perfect vehicle to deliver this message, and an archetype that the writer, who was himself a highly-accomplished academic, knew better than most. Find Whistle and I'll Come to You (1968 & 2010) ( Whistle and I'll Come to You (1968) / Whistle and I'll Come to You (2010) ) [ NON-USA FORMAT, PAL, Reg.0 Import - Australia ] by Michael Hordern at Amazon.com Movies & TV, home of thousands of titles on DVD and Blu-ray. He takes the ring back to the hotel but at night he hears loud banging on his door, even though he is the sole guest, as well as seeing a white-clad apparition that follows him on the beach.